Ryan Holiday

Who Are You Becoming?

What do a Christian historian and the world’s most popular modern Stoic have in common? More than either of them expected. Bestselling author Ryan Holiday joins Kate Bowler to explore what Stoicism can teach us about courage, character, and living with what we can’t control. They discuss why young men are searching for moral frameworks, the dangers of toxic masculinity and positive thinking, and what it actually takes to become a good person. Along the way, Kate pushes back on Stoicism’s emphasis on self-reliance and asks whether we can accept reality as it is without giving up on hope for what it could become.

LISTEN ON YOUR FAVORITE PLATFORM:

What do a Christian historian and the world’s most popular modern Stoic have in common? More than either of them expected. Bestselling author Ryan Holiday joins Kate Bowler to explore what Stoicism can teach us about courage, character, and living with what we can’t control. They discuss why young men are searching for moral frameworks, the dangers of toxic masculinity and positive thinking, and what it actually takes to become a good person. Along the way, Kate pushes back on Stoicism’s emphasis on self-reliance and asks whether we can accept reality as it is without giving up on hope for what it could become.

Transcript

Kate Bowler: There are certain philosophies that become very compelling when life is especially chaotic. They hand you a little checklist. Here is what you can control, here is what can’t. And one of the most common versions of this that we encounter is modern Stoicism. I’m Kate Bowler, and this is Everything Happens. So in last week’s conversation, I spoke with my friend Warren Smith about ancient Stoicism, like where it came from, what early Christians borrowed from it, and when Christianity eventually said, well, hang on a minute, we have some pretty fundamental disagreements here. Stoicism has this very high view of our ability to govern ourselves. Like we might not be able to control what happens, but we can control how we respond. And it asks us to accept reality as it is, to loosen our grip on outcomes, and to become people of courage and character anyway. And if you haven’t listened to that episode, you could hit pause and go do that now. It just gives you a lot of extra context into some of the nuances of where modern stoicism came from and where it comes into conflict with Christianity, and it is linked in the show notes. Okay, so as you know and have likely noticed, I am professionally suspicious of any philosophy that promises us too much power, too much agency, too much I get to choose. I’m also extremely attached to what Augustine might call slightly disordered compassion. The shared tears, the loving, the being absolutely wrecked because someone else is hurting–which stoicism doesn’t really make a lot of room for. But maybe my biggest disagreement is about hope. Christianity insists on the strange possibility that we can accept what is true without believing that it’s all there will ever be. So, enter Ryan Holiday. Ryan is probably the person most responsible for the modern revival of Stoicism. He’s the best-selling author of books like The Obstacle is the Way, Ego is the Enemy, and Stillness is the Key. Around 600,000 people open his daily Stoic email every morning, his podcast has been downloaded over 150 million times, and his version of Stoicism has found an enormous audience among men who are looking for something our culture is perhaps not particularly good at giving them: a framework, practices, responsibilities, a vocabulary for character, a way to ask, who am I becoming? So Ryan and I taped two conversations back to back that day, one for Ryan’s show and this one for mine. And I discovered something slightly irritating. Two people with some fairly significant philosophical disagreements agree on an awful lot. We both totally distrust positive thinking. We both hate the idea that you can manifest your way into a better life. We both worry about what happens when self-improvement becomes just another exhausting religion. And we both want practices that help us become less terrible to one another. There’s also a very brief mention of Ivanka Trump later that might need a little bit of context. Ryan had publicly criticized her use of stoic ideas because, as he explains, he thinks Stoicism can’t just be inspirational language about controlling your thoughts–its claims about virtue have to show up in how you actually live. So anyway, that’s just to explain his comment. But this is not a conversation in which Ryan and I settle whether Stoism is correct. But it is a conversation about what an old philosophy might offer us now. How to live with what we can’t control, how to practice courage when pretending that we are invulnerable, how to become the kind of people who can meet a difficult world without becoming cruel. Ryan Holiday, I am so glad we’re doing this. So I’m, will you take me back to like 19 year old Ryan who discovers stoicism? You’re reading Marcus Aurelius?
Ryan Holiday: As you know, Marcus Aurelius was the first stoic. I got recommended Epictetus, but when I went on Amazon, Marcus also came up.
Kate Bowler: He’s your gateway drug.
Ryan Holiday: He’s the gateway drug probably because I’d seen Gladiator and this is closer to Gladiator than not Gladiator. This would have been 2006.
Kate Bowler: What did you find in that book that really spoke to you, both like the what is stoicism and then also the like, why did it meet you, you think in that moment?
Ryan Holiday: I think the ideas in and aside, I remember I was taking a class called Philosophy 101, The Meaning of Life, and we were reading Aristotle and all these other philosophers. And I think by and large, what I was struck by reading Marcus Aurelius is I understood what he was talking about. Like there was no confusion. There was no terms that I had to look up. There wasn’t this big framework. He basically opens the book with going like, people are going to be annoying and dishonest and all these things. You can’t let that surprise you. And then by the way, it’s your job not to let them make you like them. And, and so I think I was, I was really struck by philosophy as being that as opposed to…
Kate Bowler: A big cosmology where you need like a, I mean, we’re on the drive-in, we’re in a part of Texas that seems very Christian. I saw a lot of billboards. So I imagine like, it doesn’t require a lot of like mythology and cosmology to be practical and useful.
Ryan Holiday: Yes, yeah, you’re not like, okay, wait, what’s the Trinity again? And then…
Kate Bowler: I mean, our best marketing feature is super easy to explain.
Ryan Holiday: I mean, just even reading Aristotle, you’re like, okay, Eudaimonia, that’s kind of like happiness, but it’s actually different than happiness. And then, I mean like his famous work, you can’t even pronounce the title. It’s like, is it Nicomachean or what is it? And so there is something about the Stoics that is just so much more immediately accessible and practical and that the purpose of philosophy was to help you with the difficulties of life as opposed to this kind of intellectual pursuit. I think that that was, that was very big for me.
Kate Bowler: Yeah. And then what did you, what did you, like when you define Stoicism for people in general, like I imagine this got baked in very early on. You’re like, this is, this is my account of Stoicism.
Ryan Holiday: You don’t control what happens, you control what you respond to what happens. I do think at some level, that’s what the Stoics are saying. Look, you don’t control by and large the world, but you control who you are in the world, like what kind of person you’re gonna be. And I think that was something I took from it. And I like a lot of young men that read it, I was initially attracted to the resiliency and the productivity and the rationality, all that. I think it has a philosophy, I mean, obviously there’s virtue elements in there, but I think, you know, there’s like arete virtue, like excellence, and then there’s sort of moral arete. I think I was more attracted to just excellence, generally performance, self-command, et cetera. And I think it took a longer time to understand the sort of moral and ethical elements of the philosophy.
Kate Bowler: Older Ryan, seasoned Ryan.
Ryan Holiday: But I mean, I think at its core, it was just a world that made sense to me. And not that I got it all initially and I could apply it all, initially, but I was like, oh, this is a, I can at least, I at least know where I’m going with this.
Kate Bowler: Yeah. You worked as a research assistant for Robert Greene, and I…can’t help but notice how very different in tone your books are. I don’t mean to tee you up to try to say something negative about probably someone who’s obviously a friend, but for people who haven’t read like Laws of Power, they’re quite like Machiavellian and sort of brass tacks kind of brutal about the world as it is without a lot of sort of flourish on what it could be. And I just, I wonder how you went from that framework to be like, I’m just gonna write about virtues.
Ryan Holiday: You know, it’s funny. I think the 48 laws of power is interesting because there is such a big contrast between the book itself and the guy who wrote it. But I think what he’s trying to do in that book is describe the world as it is, as opposed to the world, as he would like it to be. And it is sort of his point is that, actually, if you want to be effective in the world, like if you wanna make the world better, like if you don’t have an understanding of these, these are the people that get eaten alive by those people, right? So I think there’s an element of that in the book. He has a way of taking a bunch of different people who in some cases had no idea that each other existed, but we’re all circling and saying or experiencing similar things. And he synthesizes it down into these kind of observable patterns. And so what I took from him from a craft standpoint was how to do that. So it’s like…
Kate Bowler: Almost like a devotional format around a principle or…
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, like how do you take the things that the Stokes are talking about and illustrate them or break, because like take even something like Marcus Auerlius’ Meditations, it’s 12 books of miscellaneous numbered points. And so there are themes, but they’re not arranged in any kind of order and there are sort of patterns. And, so what I kind of took my job to be as I write about the philosophy is like how do I take something that strikes me, like in book five, where he’s talking about obstacles? Okay, what did the Stoics say about obstacles and then what are examples of that being applied throughout history by them or people who had no idea they were applying? So that primarily what I took, I would say Robert Greene’s primary influences on me, aside from just actually being a wonderful person were stylistic, and sort of thematic. So I think, again, what people sometimes skip over with his books is an understanding that he’s not saying he likes that things are this way. He’s saying that, hey, more often than not, successful people tend to be threatened by the people underneath them. And if you think that your boss is just gonna celebrate that you’re a kid going places, just you wait, you know, you bet you, and so actually, if you don’t want to trigger that defensiveness in them, you should do X, Y, or Z. That, that, that’s how I take it.
Kate Bowler: Descriptive, not prescriptive.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, it’s like, look, gravity, gravity is responsible for all sorts of heinous things.
Kate Bowler: I blame it directly for every fall I’ve made.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, we don’t blame Newton for describing the laws of it.
Kate Bowler: When you first are working with these primary sources, I imagine that at that time, most of what’s around you is like a largely symbolic, like from Hollywood, Gladiator, there’s, I think there was like bestselling books quoting cool stoic guys, with like, there’s like a man in full, like a gateway of something about a gate and fire.
Ryan Holiday: Oh, gates of fire.
Kate Bowler: Gates of fire. You can tell. Okay, that’s good. You know, this is obviously my genre.
Ryan Holiday: All the Roman Empire stuff that dudes think about all the time.
Kate Bowler: Constantly. Yes. When you were first kind of imagining the stoic universe, it sounds like you were mostly dealing with, like… Creative secondary work or primary sources, but there probably wasn’t a lot of like “how to stoic” at the time.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, I think that’s right. Um, I mean, and I guess, uh, I’m not even really dealing with the primary texts as I’m reading the English translations, like I’m not, I am not reading them in Greek or Latin. Um, but yeah, there wasn’t, um, it, it certainly wasn’t like a big niche. There was a handful of books that had been a translation of Epictetus by this woman named Sharon Lebell. That was sort of more like a TV movie style translation, like just sort of vaguely called The Art of Living, which is a Cretetus that had done pretty well. And I believe William Irvine had done a book called The Guide to the Good Life. I don’t know how well it had done, but, but I knew obviously about Robert’s works. So I knew that was a genre, and then I had, I knew that like in the eighties there’d been a bunch of like, you know. Like the art of war had been popular like on Wall Street and stuff. So I knew there was some way that sometimes if you could get it right, you could make classics or historical things relevant to a business audience. So when I was working on the obstacles away, I was primarily thinking, how do I take this philosophy and tie it to this one specific thing?
Kate Bowler: And that book exploded. Yeah, I mean.
Ryan Holiday: Kind of.
Kate Bowler: Tell me about, tell me about what happened.
Ryan Holiday: You know, so my publisher had, they offered me less than half what I’d gotten for my first book, for What Became the Obstacles of Life. So like they didn’t think it was going to explode. And certainly I didn’t think it was gonna explode or I would have, I was not unpleased, you know, I was like, this seems cool. I was pretty excited. Pretty excited.
Kate Bowler: You’re like, I bought this bust. I got all these books.
Ryan Holiday: I did actually buy it. I have it on my desk. I bought this little bust of Mark’s Cerritos.
Kate Bowler: The second I decided I was going to academia, I was like, I’m getting at least five busts.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, but, I was like, I get to write a book about stoicism. I was very excited. So I wasn’t at all insulted, but like, let’s just say expectations were managed. And when it came out, maybe it sold 3,000 copies the first week, which is not a flop, but it’s not like people in publishing were not like, oh my God, um and, and it probably sold half that the second week and half that again, the third week. So it was like a little blip and then, you know, it never went to zero, but at some point, like a year later, it started getting picked up in sports, which is not at all what I thought, like that’s not the audience that I was imagining.
Kate Bowler: So is this the Patriots?
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, someone in the front office of the New England Patriots read it and they invited me out to a game and I met some people and I sort of thought that was like.
Kate Bowler: The coolest ever.
Ryan Holiday: The coolest, and yeah, again, not what you expect. I was like, I got to go to a free Patriots game. And then they ended up winning the Super Bowl that year. And they were not at all, it hadn’t been, it wasn’t like one of those seasons where you’re like, they could go all the way. Like it was a pretty, you know, and they beat the Seahawks in this kind of crazy game that goes down to a play on the one yard line at the end of the game. And so again, pretty cool. Then that summer, I’m assuming I’m getting all the dates wrong, that summer I got a Google alert or something for an ESPN article or a Sports Illustrated article that I read that mentioned that the Seahawks were reading it. And I go, that’s weird. How could the Seahawks be reading it? And so I messaged the person that I knew at the Patriots and I said, does this have anything to do with you? And he said, yeah, we were just at a draft workout for some quarterbacks. And I gave it to the GM of the Seahawks, and then now they’re reading it. And so it was just a surreal process by which these people started passing the book around. And then that kind of slowly happened in a bunch of different areas.
Kate Bowler: Tell me about the analogy between that particular book and like, what do you think was happening in what is required in elite? I only know a little bit about like, how teams are made, the kind of moral framework that they need to live inside those grueling conditions. Like, what did you think it was about the book that really touched them?
Ryan Holiday: The interesting thing about sports is like, CEOs of rival companies don’t give each other book recommendations that often. As far as sports goes, I do think people think, oh, these people must spend a lot of time drawing up plays. Like that the advantages are eeked out over, you know, coming up with a new formation or like all, but all those gains are…sort of eaten away, like they’re all equally good at some level at the thing. And so it really comes down more to the sort of mental side of things of like, okay, how do we bounce back after a loss? How does a player deal with an injury? How do we keep ego at bay? How do, where do we get sort of toughness and focus and all of those things like. So you find that the people in sports, the coaches particular, but then definitely, like maybe the supernaturally talented athletes are just kind of doing their own thing, but like most of the time, that’s what they’re focused on. It’s like, how do I handle the stress, the criticism, the distractions, the grind of it. Like that’s what they are all kind of looking for.
Kate Bowler: Do you give inspirational sports talks sometimes?
Ryan Holiday: I don’t know how inspirational they are, but I’ve spoken to many sports teams.
Kate Bowler: I have been asked to give a couple of these talks. I want you to know how badly suited Christianity is to Sports Talks.
Ryan Holiday: I would say the opposite. It’s the worst. But I mean, almost all of the teams have Bible study groups.
Kate Bowler: Yeah, they do. But theologically, it’s like, we’re a religion of losers. Our God dies badly. It’s all based on a resurrection that’s not up to us. I’ve tried, and I find it not in any way useful. I gave one to a team last year. You could tell after they’re like, okay.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, okay, so definitely I’m not sure how interested they’re hearing theologically or philosophically, which is actually one of the best pieces of advice I got. I don’t know if you know who John Gordon is. He writes these little books that are very popular in sports, but I remember he’s talked to every sports human who could possibly imagine. And he was just like, just know like the athletes don’t wanna hear from you. And I was like, what? And he’s like, they don’t like, they don’t want to go to this meeting that you’re speaking at. Just to be clear, he’s like, you get one or two things you can tell them and you got to get out of there as quickly as possible. I think the fantasy is you’ll go in there and give this raw motivational talk and they’re just not interested at all. But if you can go in and you can say, hey, here are three ideas that have stood the test of time, or here’s something I’m thinking about, or here is a story I thought I’d leave you with. That can sometimes resonate but unless you are like actually like a legit preacher or like an athlete yourself, you are…
Kate Bowler: How dare you. Okay, let’s move on from this line of work.
Ryan Holiday: Kobe Bryant could go in and give an inspirational, like, you know, like the, because they do, they’ll have former athletes come in and those guys can get in there and tell some stories or like the special forces people. Like, there’s some people who can, who can have a commanding enough presence that they’ll sit up in their chairs and listen. But most of us, you have to remember your primary audience is the coach. The coach wants to hear you. Because he or she read your book and that’s who you’re performing for.
Kate Bowler: Do you think there’s something about, like when it first moved through sports world and then it sounds like it had analogies where it like, it does very well in the military? What are the other groups that it does really well in?
Ryan Holiday: I mean, my UK publisher sent me a picture yesterday of Volodymyr Zelenskyy handing a copy of one of my books to the ambassador of Sweden.
Kate Bowler: Oh my gosh.
Ryan Holiday: And you’re just like, whoa, okay, that’s, that’s crazy. So it tends to be any kind of community that is, I don’t want to say insular, but it tends to be…
Kate Bowler: High walls, high focus.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, just where they’re all going through the same thing. Military has been won, politics has been one, sports has been on, like finance will be one, BC will be on, dentists or trauma specialists or some of them are so specific. One, I gave a talk in Dallas maybe two years ago and the group was, it was a conference for doctors who own the building they’re practicing in.
Kate Bowler: That’s good, that’s good.
Ryan Holiday: Like, so they’re basically entrepreneurial real estate focused doctors.
Kate Bowler: That’s good. You’re like as Epictetus said of that similar scenario.
Ryan Holiday: He also owned a small building outside of Rome.
Kate Bowler: Marcus Aurelius owned an empire’s worth of buildings. I mean, and setting aside that there are very interesting feminist readings of stoicism and that surely it’s popular with lots of women, I just, I’m sure you’ve seen up close just what a wild west of possible options of masculinity there are right now. And that there are, I mean, from insane diet options to many very upsetting versions of the manosphere, that this probably offers a very constructive, virtues-focused, all things considered, masculine but doesn’t read as, like what? How would you help fill in that sentence?
Ryan Holiday: No, I would like to think so. I remember some journalist was doing like a, it’s funny like at first the trend pieces are positive and then…
Kate Bowler: Sure, they’re like, he’s had enough success.
Ryan Holiday: If it works, then the trend pieces are negative, right? And like to remember that it was like, I was just trying to get anyone to care about it and then now it’s like, they are too stoic, it’s a problem. It’s funny. But I remember, you know, she was like, aren’t you concerned about these young men reading this stuff? And I go, it’s like better than the, like, compared to what, you know, like a 2000 year old virtues-based philosophy seems like the least bad of most of the options.
Kate Bowler: Oh my gosh, it had been a while, I read Stoicism in college, until getting reintroduced to you mostly, it’d been a really long time since I read stoicism. I knew that it was very openly considered a close friend and heretical cousin to Christianity, so I knew its points of disagreement and stuff. But man, when I was re-reading your work, I was like, of all possible versions of constructive masculinity right now, like, I don’t know another version that’s going to offer virtues language for people who are not typically in like an institution. They’re not going to have like a framework for moral progress, typically.
Ryan Holiday: And I think that’s why it spoke to me and why, like when people look out at this sort of array of options as you’re talking about, and they’re like, why are so many people choosing the pan options? I think we have to look in the mirror and go, well, did you present the alternatives? Like, I think, you know, I would say most young men are growing up in kind of a moral vacuum. Like, unless you’re, you now, enlisted in the armed forces or you come from a really strong religious tradition and obviously from, from some of your work, you know, like how much, even some of the religious tradition is, is got picked up these sort of toxic values of it’s, it’s more like this kind of political cult than a like a framework for living. So you know, when we’re not living in a tribe or a that has these like coming of age rituals or these sort of shared myths and stories, I think a lot of young men grow up and they’re just sort of like, okay, what am I supposed to do and not do? Like, I mean, I know vaguely what’s legal and illegal and I know what’s kind of vaguely frowned upon, but I’m not totally sure why. And I mean I seem to see over here the people that are getting attention and celebrated and they’re doing all these things. It’s both a civics problem and kind of a spiritual philosophical problem where we, we didn’t, we haven’t really explained what our values are. And then, and then somebody comes along and says, all those values are bullshit, they don’t matter. I actually do X, Y, and Z to get ahead. And then we’re like surprised that people are listening.
Kate Bowler: This is one of the real frustrations, she said lovingly and respectfully, about like center left Christianity, is people, I mean, of most faiths who describe as cosmopolitan, what it mostly means is culturally porous. So they won’t usually then create their own magazines or music or, cause they’re like, oh no, if I want to read about it, I’ll just read the New York Times. But if they don’t make anything, then they don’t have anything to actually share the constructive parts of their values. So I totally agree. I do think that especially when we’re a little bit more, you know, want to be open and conversant with the world, those people are much less likely to create constructive norms.
Ryan Holiday: And we talked earlier about kind of know-it-allism. I think they’re all in the sort of center left or even academic tradition over the last, let’s say a hundred years. There’s been a lot of work at sort of puncturing myths and stories. So, you know, let me tell you everything terrible about Thomas Jefferson and let me, let’s tear down the statues of these people and those people. Let me tell actually why Columbus was bad and all that is, you know, I mean, sometimes it goes to extremes and like the scholarship itself there is bad, but most of it is true. But if you don’t, if you throw the baby out with the bathwater or you don’t create any compelling alternative stories, or you, you don’t tell a more well-rounded but still inspiring story. Like I think about this being in the South of the Civil War. We sort of allowed after the Civil War for this sort of lost cause mythology. And there’s a Confederate statue right down the street from here. That’s wrong and that story needs to be debunked, but it has to be replaced with a more inspiring story about what Reconstruction was actually about and how close we got and what that sort of brief moment of multiracial democracy was like. And then the hundred years leading up then to the civil rights movement and you have to tell, you can’t just tear down, you have build up. And so I do think we created this vacuum and then we’re surprised when Andrew Tate shows up in your kid’s algorithm and they’re like, well, there’s none of the equivocation or self-hatred or whimpering patheticness that’s not resonating with me over here. And they just don’t have the skills to know that actually this is a disgraced sex trafficker, internet marketer. And so it’s seen like, in the absence of good, compelling role models and stories, those people break through the noise.
Kate Bowler: And some of the things that you, I just find like big teachables that you do are very like…reading, attention span, like focus. When you look at your audience profile, and I’m sure you know them really well after this number of years, like are they in their 30s, are they new dads, are they older guys? Like what’s the primary kind of person that’s looking for that kind of moral formation right now?
Ryan Holiday: It’s much more diverse than you would think.
Kate Bowler: They’re gonna do Gallop reports I swear to you in like two years and they’re going like do you have a studied indifference to reality as it is? You’re like, if so, blame Ryan Holliday.
Ryan Holiday: The APA did some study of the three traits of toxic masculinity and lowercase stoicism was one of them.
Kate Bowler: Stop.
Ryan Holiday: And you’re just like, it’s like, I get what you’re saying. And at the same time, are you looking at this society and you’re like, no, no these people are too self-controlled. Like it’s nonsense. That’s the opposite of our problem.
Kate Bowler: It does seem like it went from adjacent to other religious traditions, compatible. Is it like a, because in the version where it’s like a practical way of living, then it feels like it could be added on to any number of almost complimentary worldviews.
Ryan Holiday: I think that’s what it’s become. There’s a Flaubert quote that I like where he says, between Cicero and Marcus Aurelius, when the gods had ceased to be and Christ had not yet come, man stood alone in the universe. And his point was that, like, I think he was saying that’s the sort of the heyday of philosophy, like that period. The timing makes no sense there because I mean, Marcus Aurelius persecutes the Christians. So like, you know, there’s like, Marcus Aurelius comes 150 years after Christ. So like that doesn’t totally make sense really at all. But I think the point of like, okay, when the old, the sort of polytheistic system is kind of sputtering out and before the…
Kate Bowler: I see. Rise up.
Ryan Holiday: Monotheism. There is this kind of period where you’re like, where Stoicism is the, Stoism and Epicureanism are the two dominant sort of philosophical frameworks. And then Epicureanism kind of falls away. Stoicism, the cardinal virtues of it get built into Christianity. So I think it’s very compatible with Christianity.
Kate Bowler: So then would you read the story like, so secularization casts a very wide shadow over religion in the modern West. We now have a very confusing assortment of civil religion, major and minor religious traditions in North America. And then would you consider then Stoicism like a philosophical, I don’t want to say like sidebar, but like…
Ryan Holiday: I do think it’s like the secularization trend you’re talking about becomes, creates room for philosophy in a way that wasn’t like, like something else was answering those questions before. And by that, I mean like, not just religion was answering that question, but so too was like patriotism and nationalism and the Kiwanis club. And like there was also the Masons.
Kate Bowler: You have a very nice Masonic group down the street, I saw.
Ryan Holiday: And like, I’m sure there’s 17 people in town that belong to it, but the vast majority of us, like, it’s just a building that you drive by. Kind of like for a lot of people, a church is just like a thing you drive by or maybe you go once or twice a year. It’s not really like your guiding, animating sort of explanation for why you should be a good person.
Kate Bowler: Yeah, how dare you. And I just, the other part that seemed, I know it wasn’t the same timeline, but like, this as a moral framework after social media creates this very strange, like, faux parallelism where everybody, like you’re everywhere and nowhere. Do you think it, I just, I imagine that that creates a different kind of experience of individualism that would make an individualistic philosophy. I mean, you don’t need a religion of, it would be a great religion of the internet if there’s not necessarily a communal feeling.
Ryan Holiday: I think there’s something to that. I also think what social media and sort of modern abundance does is it creates a need for like what Marcus Aurelius is wrestling with. Like I can do whatever I want. I can be whoever I want, no one can tell me what to do. But I understand at some level that when I do anything and everything I want I’m actually miserable. Like what Viktor Frankl calls the existential vacuum, that I think is there when things are really bad and also when things aren’t really good. And so I think part of the thing that Stoicism is addressing is this like everything is awesome and I’m not happy or everything is also and I don’t feel awesome. What’s up?
Kate Bowler: And then like the desire to have constraint, then, that makes a lot of sense.
Ryan Holiday: And it, you know, Societism does ask a lot, but it doesn’t require a leap of faith exactly.
Kate Bowler: In your, so the, obviously stoicism has like a debate internal to it about whether the Logos, like the reason, the living according to nature requires a deity or not, and I know, but do you secretly have like a view on that?
Ryan Holiday: I don’t know if I secretly have one. I think it’s funny, right around the time I was discovering Stoicism, I remember this was sort of the heyday of the Richard Dawkins and the Sam Harris and that sort of like, so there was something in the air then too, where it’s like, well, obviously this is all bullshit. And like, you’re an idiot if you possibly believe in any of this stuff, which sort of growing up Catholic, I took pretty hard. And I think what resonated with me about stoicism is in a way, it’s the same moral principles. I mean, literally the same cardinal virtues, but it’s not saying God said so. It’s just saying like, hey, don’t you notice when you’re not living this way, something doesn’t feel right or it’s not working.
Kate Bowler: It’s very experientially derived. Yeah. And I can see how it offers a very like, I’m just making up words like scorn-free…
Ryan Holiday: There’s no, there’s not like shame, you know, or it’s like, I think I’ve said this before, but I feel like the stoics are not saying, hey, if you do these things or don’t do these things, you’ll go to hell. It’s like you’ll live in hell, like life will be hell. And the stoic are looking at, they’re going, hey it’s not fun to be Nero guys. Like Nero, Nero was having a really bad time. It was a form of torture. And you do find there’s almost, it’s kind of like, there’s like an Ecclesiastes vibe…
Kate Bowler: Yes, an Ecclesiastes vibe, yes.
Ryan Holiday: In Seneca especially, where he’s like, look at this pathetic old man who’s still trying to get rich and powerful. Epictetus tells us this story of watching somebody suck up to Nero’s cobbler to win Nero’s favor. So they’re just describing these things that on the one hand are very ancient and on the other hand have such obvious modern analogies. And so you’re just kind of like, oh yeah, that kind of emptiness and unhappiness and insatiability, like that’s the real punishment for wanting things outside of your control.
Kate Bowler: When you think about the people who are being drawn to Stoicism, that are like, you’re their first entry point and they’re going in, is that person getting younger and younger?
Ryan Holiday: I guess it’s probably from the social media element of things. There it does skew younger. But I do think it’s speaking to a need that, especially as you’re coming of age, we do a bad job of this, as a society of…
Kate Bowler: Moral formation.
Ryan Holiday: Moral formation, and then also even just like ceremony and transition, right? Like, you go to college and it’s mayhem and then maybe you graduate from college and then we’re like, welcome to the real world kid, you know, you’re on your own now. But there’s, there isn’t–maybe like a bar mitzvah–like we don’t have a lot of kind of ceremonies and structures by which you graduate and assume different responsibilities.
Kate Bowler: And you, I think you have really tapped into, I think especially men’s desire to like be on that hero’s journey at last. I do, cause like, if they don’t have a feeling of, progress, practices, specific practices that they can engage in, reflection, and then requirement.
Ryan Holiday: I think the problem is we, other people have stepped in to fill that space and it’s always going to be more attractive and viral to be like, the reason you are feeling angst and lonely and uncertainty is, is because, you know, like society has, has, um, has lifted up women too far or it’s because, you know…
Kate Bowler: I feel too elevated sometimes. It’s exhausting being up here.
Ryan Holiday: I got this thing that like they were talking about empathy and it’s like, is your honest contention that…
Kate Bowler: Oh, is this toxic empathy?
Ryan Holiday: You look around and you just think our general problem is that we’re too empathetic as a society. There’s people fucking dying all over the world of totally preventable things and people are literally dying deaths of despair and we’re too nice? So we’re just too nice, that’s why that’s happening. Nonsense.
Kate Bowler: Do you think, is Stoicism’s competitors, like, effectively…
Ryan Holiday: Nihilism, I think, nihilism and cynicism and grievance, right? It’s like, look, do you want to have to take responsibility for your life and your feelings and, you know, the sort of state of play, or would you like it to be somebody else’s fault? And it’s been interesting to watch because originally when my stuff came out, it was very well received by people on the right. And I could, I could even feel there was like, I would get invited to these conferences or these dinners. And I can tell, like people would say things like, there’s any way we can support what you’re doing, just let us know. Like I could tell there was kind of like a blank check or opening of the checkbook kind of things that were happening. And then as the sort of political situation has evolved, that has, I can feel the winds of that shifting, even ironically as they’re paying more and more lip service to the idea of virtue.
Kate Bowler: I saw Ivanka. Ivanka Trump has some nice things to say about Stoicism. And you were, I mean, I had forgotten until you were talking about it, just how openly like anti-corruption, anti, what’s the word for like, slovenly praise for authorities?
Ryan Holiday: Oh, sycophancy?
Kate Bowler: Sycophancy, there we go, yeah.
Ryan Holiday: I mean, there’s a Wikipedia page for a group of Stoics that’s just called the Stoic Opposition. Like they just hated emperors, they hated tyrants, they hated corruption and dysfunction and incompetence. It’s funny that video, people got so mad about that. I wasn’t even really making a political point. She was talking about, there was this passage, when the Stoics talk about how our life has died by the color of our thoughts and that basically what we think about and what we say determines like the world we live in. And, you know, to hear Ivanka Trump, a daughter of literally the most negative and like nasty, grievance-based, head of state in the history of the Western world. You don’t believe that, like, you don’t believe that or, and I said, you don’t think that or you’d have an intervention with your father. I don’t mean you would have a political intervention. I mean, you would just say, Dad, you’re killing yourself by sending these tweets out at four in the morning. Like that just struck me as such, like such bullshit. Like that’s really what I was reacting to, you know, cause I hate, sometimes people will take that quote also and be like, oh, so you believe in like manifesting and stuff. And it’s like, I hate that too. And if that’s where she’d gone, I would have called that out also. Like it’s not this, you don’t just get to think positive thoughts and the world is positive. And if you think negative thoughts, the world is negative. That’s not like what they’re saying at all.
Kate Bowler: It is, sorry, that was one of the first things I decided I liked about you, that we both shared our anti-positive thinking. It is very strange that the like, Norman Vincent Peale, the father of positive thinking, was Donald Trump’s pastor.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, it’s very strange and surreal and kind of this upside-down world that we’re living in where you have this political movement that’s talking a lot about virtue and the need for traditional values and virtue and what happened and blah blah by literally the least virtuous people in the history of American public life. We’re not making an exception. Obviously, every elected leader in American history who also owned slaves was a profoundly immoral person. It’s just insane to me that we went from virtue signaling as the main problem to like vice signaling, like just the open celebration of cruelty and like, you know, like even the military, which is in a violent business, did not until recently post on their social media videos of them killing people. Like there was this sense that they were professionals tasked with doing a fundamentally unpleasant and awful thing, but like they understood that with that power came responsibility and surprise. Like it’s a very weird cultural sort of a storm that we’re in.
Kate Bowler: No, it totally is. Even though Stoicism is a version of everything happening for a reason, and it doesn’t love disordered compassion as much as I do. And it has a huge focus on agency, which are all three things I truly hate.
Ryan Holiday: Sure.
Kate Bowler: I just have to say, I think we just have so much in common, and I’ve had such a good time talking to you, Ryan. Thank you. Thanks so much for doing this.
Ryan Holiday: Yeah, of course.
Kate Bowler: I keep thinking about how very irritating it is when someone or something you disagree about turns out to be, you know, like useful. There are still parts of stoicism that I’m going to pick fights with until I die, especially when it starts to sound like we should be able to manage our way through every terrible thing or despair. And that’s just a magic solution instead of hope. I want a room full of tears and grief. I want interdependence. I want the kind of hope that pulls us into the future, that doesn’t just ask that we rely upon ourselves. But I’ve really loved Ryan’s insistence that character is something we practice, that courage and responsibility and being less awful to each other might require habits and not just good intentions. So here’s a little blessing for all of us trying to live, you know, alongside all that we can’t control. Blessed are you who are tired of trying to get everything right. May you know what is yours to carry and what was never yours to control. May courage be enough for you today. May your tears not embarrass you. May you need other people without apology, and may hope find you still. All right, my loves, I can’t wait to hear what you think of this episode. Come on and find me at Substack. We keep talking about all of this, the beautiful and the terrible and the completely ridiculous parts about being a person. And if you haven’t ever been over on Substack, just like go take a look, it’s totally free. Kate Bowler at Substack.com. And of course, the sixth love language is sharing interesting podcast episodes with friends. So if this made you think of anyone, send it to them. It’s almost always a guy that’s interested in Stoicism. So, you know, send it to a dude friend. I hope this sparks some thoughtful debate in your group chat. Everything Happens Studios is made possible through the generous support of Lilly Endowment and my team, Jess Ritchie, Harriet Putman, Anne Herring, Hailie Durrett, Megan Crunkleton, and Katherine Smith. Thank you, loves. This is Everything Happen with me, Kate Bowler.

Ryan Holiday

Ryan Holiday is a #1 New York Times bestselling author and one of the world’s best-known writers on Stoicism and its place in modern life. His books, including The Obstacle Is the Way, Ego Is the Enemy, and Stillness Is the Key, have sold millions of copies, been translated into more than 40 languages, and become unlikely favorites in NFL locker rooms, Fortune 500 boardrooms, and the military. Ryan runs the Daily Stoic podcast and newsletter, which reaches millions of readers each day. He lives on a small ranch outside Austin, Texas, with his wife and two sons, where he also owns The Painted Porch, an independent bookstore in historic downtown Bastrop.

Ryan Holiday