Discussion Questions
1. Psychologist Abigail Marsh is both a recipient of and expert in extraordinary altruism. In other words, she’s well-versed in people who put their life on the line for others when it doesn’t serve them, genetically or socially. What’s the most extraordinary example of extraordinary altruism you’ve ever experienced?
2. Research suggests that we’re more likely to help those who we’re related to or in close proximity to. But the question of where our body ends and another’s begins—is not so clear. (Remember the rubber hand experiment.) Have you ever felt someone else to be an extension of your own “me-ness?” Was that someone else a loved one, a stranger, a community? What does this suggest about your capacity for empathy?
3. “Most people,” Dr. Marsh thinks, “have the capacity to develop these really strong, empathic feelings for people who are very different from themselves if they are in the right frame of mind.” What do you think she means by “the right frame of mind” and what practices help get you/us there?
4. Marsh has also studied the flip side of empathy: psychopathy. But instead of feeling depressed by the research, she says it’s been reassuring to realize that selfishness is not normal. There’s a range of compassion and most of us are very capable of caring for others. What reassures you about being on a spectrum of altruism?
5. One of the common misconceptions about psychopathy and other psychological disorders is that they’re a result of bad parenting (and, more specifically, Mom’s parenting). Why do you think this cause and effect has been so compelling to people for so long? Why do you think it’s more useful to think about these disorders through a disease model rather than a moral model?
6. Marsh found that the best predictor of empathy in the lab was how well someone could recognize fear in others. Does this finding surprise you? How could it reorient your relationship to fear in others—or in yourself? How could it reorient your relationship to courage in others—or in yourself?
7. “There’s this weird belief out there that to be virtuous, you have to not feel fear,” Dr. Marsh observes. But real virtue is knowing when fear is less important than serving a higher purpose. (Thanks, Aristotle.) Who do you know that lives with this kind of both/and fear and love?
8. A lot of the extraordinary organ donors Dr. Marsh has interviewed insist “I’m not that special”—even though there’s some research on their amygdalae that would suggest otherwise. They seemed to believe that belonging to each other beyond biology or proximity was just something intrinsic to all of humanity. Does their perspective inspire you to live larger? In what way? Be specific, if you can.
9. The thing that gives Dr. Marsh the most optimism about her work is the notion that “helping each other is a self-reinforcing process.” This isn’t exactly selfish. It’s just how altruism works. Bringing other people joy is more satisfying than drawing resources to yourself. What does knowing this give you permission to pursue, “selfishly and beautifully”?
10. “We can all develop a bit more compassion for people who are dissimilar from us, to see people expressing fear or distress and move toward them,” Kate reflects. So, who will you move toward today?
Bonus: After listening to this week’s podcast, what part of Kate & Dr. Marsh’s conversation resonated with you most? What insight will you carry with you?
Discussion Questions written by author, editor, and facilitator Erin S. Lane.